Last updated : 19th May 2013



Man Without a Past
Rogue


Episode Title In the Public Interest
Story Synopsis A city's Chief Constable has imposed a virtual police state, resulting in little crime – except from his own officers who infringe suspects' rights in their pursuit of "zero tolerance".
Writer Brian Clemens
Director Pennant Roberts
Series 2
UK Episode # B05
UK Tx Date 04 November 1978
Production # Block 2, Ep 6
Approx Filming Dates 14th - 25th August 1978
Guest Stars Stephen Rea, John Judd, Tom Georgeson
Dave's Comment Story
Action
Pace
Humour
Violence

An interesting idea: is it possible to curb crime completely and still remain true to the law yourself? An excellent story. Strange, though, why the actual name of the town is never used: one could easily have invented one without offending anybody.

Of course the irony here - and one that Brian Clemens, ever mindful of the dubious morals of CI5, deliberately worked into the dialogue - is that Chief Constable Green's tactics and self-appointed powers are uncomfortably close to Cowley's. For example Green encourages Inspector Chives to make judgments based on instincts: "I like instincts: they can't be put down on paper!". This is alarmingly close to the CI5's "Sniff hard, be alert" and "By whatever means necessary - that's our loophole" attitudes espoused in the first season. Indeed Cowley even protests about Green exercising "unbridled power! That's the thing I've been fighting against all my life! " - yet, as we know, CI5's own remit is challenged as being omnipotent throughout the series - the earlier 'The Rack' being the prime example.

There are some great humorous moments: see Sharon's "eyelash" comment, the lads in their hotel room, the drunken man and his Nazi salute (which counterpoints with an earlier comment by Cowley).

Great to see the excellent Allan Surtees back as the Minister - and wonderful chemistry with Gordon/Cowley. A pity he didn't become a regular fixture in the show.

Paul Hardwick plays the Chief Constable as paternal and caring, genuinely believing in his own ideals, although clearly knowing that his own men have to bend the law to achieve them - again, so reflective of Cowley and CI5. And the script beautifully "plays" Green on this: his ego leads him to believe that the real purpose of Cowley's visit is to hand over the reins of The Big A!

As ever with this show, the support stars are super, too, especially those playing Green's men. John Judd gives a wonderfully steely performance as Chives, a copper who clearly relishes being his boss' "enforcer". The underrated Colin McCormack, sadly no longer with us, plays Sergeant Edwards' attitude as nicely ambiguous until realising that the situation has been pushed too far.

An excellent episode, this is definitely one of my faves.

From one of the greatest scenes in the entire series and Gordon surpassing even his own Everest standards:

Minister: "A city sewn up tight but safely. A city where hooligans are kept in check and suspicious characters are forced to move on. For God's sake, George, to most law-abiding citizens, it sounds like Utopia!"

Cowley: "Aye... that's what they thought about Hitler's Germany."

Minister: "Green's done a wonderful job..."

Cowley: "Because he's slamming doors on porn and hoodlums and anyone who doesn't measure up to his particular standards."

Minister: "And what's wrong with..."

Cowley: "Suppose his standards change?! Suppose he suddenly clamps down on those who don't go along with his politics? Or ethnic groups? Or people who grow their hair below the Plimsoll Line? Or anyone who doesn't measure up in his opinion? Unbridled power! That's the thing I've been fighting all my life! It starts wars and it hurts people... and it's damned bloody dangerous! I can go over your head, William. I can but I don't want to..."

Minister: "Evidence! Bring me facts, George - something solid, irrefutable. I can't have you going over my head, George... ", he grins: "or then you'd really think you were God!"

Sharon's Comment

A truly excellent story. The idea that good intentions put before proper legalities leads to a corruption of the system and those with power in it is one that can never be repeated enough. I like George Cowley here too. Very much.

It's also a great Lad-watching episode. Both look terrific and the "gay" role they have to play in the second part makes it even more fun. The irony of Stephen "The Crying Game" Rea as a man who says: "I'm not a homosexual myself, but many of my friends are" is too precious!

We get some personal background on Doyle. He's from Derby, but went to school elsewhere (wherever "the lousy town" is) and was precocious sexually. "Whatd'ya mean 'first time?' I was nearly fifteen!". And he snuck into adult films using his father's overcoat. Naughty laddie.

Bodie wears black or dark brown much of the time and Doyle, with sunglasses, chest hair, silver chain, tight jeans and leather jacket, doesn't get much better ever!

The car park scene shot with the night filter is visually bothersome, but it does make both heroes look marvelous.

Note that Bodie hauls the heavy luggage, lumbering along in Doyle's wake. This is an ongoing theme we'll see over and over. There is speculation that this became an inside joke between the two of them.

The campy acting and dialogue when they check into the hotel for the second time is delightful. A frequent rewind and replay moment. Watch Ray closely when he gives his little "fractured eyelash is so much better" speech.

Watch how they know one another's physical positions when they're unloading the car. Teamwork, no matter what the task.

Bodie's (Lewis's) skin in this one is on gorgeous display. The first time I saw the episode in PAL I went wild over the pearlescent glow. No one has skin like that man! And of course, during the aborted whipping scene, we get to see more of it than usual. A very big round of applause to the writers for that bit of pleasure! That scene is well done by both actors, though the baddies are a bit boring. Would have liked a little more nastiness, but I suppose once they saw the CI5 IDs they knew they were done for.

Notice that Bodie uses Ray's first name when he spots the cops closing in on them. This happens often when things are really worrisome. Otherwise he calls him Doyle.

Doyle's trust in police as a whole is put to the test in this story and he emerges triumphant. Nice, understated byplay between them on this issue starting from the first encounter when Bodie declares that he doesn't like arrogant coppers. When Doyle dictates they surrender, Bodie's behavior and expression show just how fond of the notion he is but he does it because Doyle thinks they should.

And observe the fury in Doyle's face when Bodie is struck.

A good story of right-mindedness gone wrong.

Bloopers

On arriving arrive in the hotel room, Doyle opens his attache case, takes off his shoulder holster, removes the gun, puts it down and puts the holster on top of it. A moment later he picks up the (empty) holster and again takes the gun out to put it in the case! (Thanks to Sue Law)

When the lads are stopped for speeding, they pull up outside some houses. When they drive off again they are outside some shops instead! (See the Locations section below.) Thanks to Sue Beach for that one!

There's another "scene-shifting" flaw when the lads are giving the small-time villain a lift.

BTW
Deja Vu

Stephen Rea (Pellin) is best remembered for the oddball IRA thriller The Crying Game. (Apparently he was once actually married to a former IRA terrorist).

Tom Georgeson (Detective Sergeant Reed) also starred in the episode 'Need to Know' but is best remembered for Boys from the Blackstuff and Between the Lines.

Colin McCormack (Sgt Edwards) had a tiny role in 'The Ojuka Situation', again paying a copper! Sadly passed away, aged just 62, in 2004.

Locations
The Gay Youth offices were at 304 Kensal Road, Kensington but the building has since been replaced. However the pub the lads skulk by in order to photograph Green's men still stands.
For the police station, we only see two interior sets: the offices of Green and Chives, the latter of which is was filmed at what was about to become a mothballed site for Lee Studios, 288 Kensal Road.
Cowley leaves for home, emerging from the National Liberal Club, Whitehall Place.
Although he appears to walk east there's actually some location cheating here as the next shot is south, at the junction of Whitehall Court and Horse Guards Ave
The next three shots picture Cowley walking along Horse Guards Avenue.
Cowley's flat was in Ranelagh Gardens, Hammersmith, though there's no indication in the documentation as to whether the interiors were shot there, too.
The minister's office was filmed at the Tower Theatre, Islington, though we only see the interior.
The shopping centre was Shepherd's Bush Green but, other than nearby greenery, it's not recognisable now.
According to the documentation the Star Hotel the lads stay at was at 77 Wembley Hill Road - the house with the black door in this GSV shot - though we never see the exterior in the episode... and there's no railway line anywhere near it - the sound of the passing train was dubbed on!
The lads pick up small-time villain Terry around the back of Orbit Club on Connell Crescent, Ealing. The same location is used for the tall drunk guy that Chives & co "arrest".
The lads drop off Terry at Watford Junction station. I've had to cheat slightly with the Google Street View here to make the background buildings more obvious: although the houses have since gone, the left-hand-side of the NatWest building can be seen on the right of the screengrab.
The prison in which Doyle visits Jimmy Flynn is documented as was actually Mill Hill Gas Works on Bittacy Hill, Barnet but it's all been redeveloped since the episode was filmed.
Having witnessed abuse by Green's force, the lads decide to report back to Cowley. The shot here was taken along Orange Hill Road, Barnet, with the boys travelling north-west from the junction with Watling Avenue...
The next shot sees them further along Orange Hill Road, here at the junction with Colchester Road.
Sgt Edwards overtakes and stops the lads by this house, which can be seen on the left-hand-side of the screengrab.
After Doyle's first reprimand, we see the location blooper: having clearly stopped by houses, he pulls away from a row of shops! However it's still on Watling Avenue and the exterior stairs seen in the screengrab have since had a "roof" attached!
Doyle gets pulled over again! By an astonishing production coincidence, Edwards happens to pull up outside a house that looks remarkably similar to one seen earlier on Orange Hill Road. But this time we're on Watling Avenue.
Traffic problems necessitated a slight cheat here: the close-ups were actually filmed on Fortescue Road...
When Edwards walks away we are clearly back on Watling Avenue!!
Green entertains Cowley at the Edgwarebury Hotel, Elstree
With Green's cops after them, the lads escape around the corner of Adela Street and Kensal Road - the white-coloured building in the background still stands today, though obscured by the tree in the Google Street View.
On spying the white police car heading towards them, they scarper down West Row
The pursuit continues down West Row.
Sgt Edwards picks up the APB. Filmed on the corner of Abinger Road and Bath Road, Chiswick, this is a bizarre choice of location for a single scene as it is miles away from where the other scenes for the pursuit were filmed!
Edwards pulls up opposite what is thought to be BBC Television Centre on Wood Lane, although the area has undergone complete redevelopment since...
... while the "gasworks" scenes saw the production unit return to Mill Hill Gas Works on Bittacy Hill, Barnet (which has been redeveloped since the episode was filmed.)
After the lads surrender, Inspector Chives drives to the scene along what appears to be the aforemetioned route past the BBC on Wood Lane, judging by the design of the metal gate in comparison to the earlier screengrab.
Chives drives the lads to the quarry around Springwell Lane, Rickmansworth


Man Without a Past
Rogue

Click for the complete List of Episodes